Learn the best ways to match asphalt shingle roof colors for repairs or additions. Get expert tips on color blending, manufacturer guidelines, and visual matching to ensure a consistent look across your roof.

How to Match Asphalt Shingle Roof Colors: What Every Colorado and Georgia Homeowner Should Know

Shingle Roofing
August 08, 2025•3 min read

Shingle Color Matching: What You Need to Know Before Repairing or Replacing Your Roof

If you’re repairing or extending an asphalt shingle roof, matching the shingle color can make or break the look of your home. But color matching isn’t just about appearance—it’s also about maintaining home value and avoiding disputes with HOAs or potential buyers.

Here’s what Colorado and Georgia homeowners should understand about matching asphalt shingle roof colors effectively.

Why Shingle Color Matching Matters

  • Curb appeal: A mismatched repair stands out and can lower the perceived value of your home.

  • HOA compliance: Many Colorado and Georgia HOAs require uniform roof color.

  • Home resale: Buyers often spot shingle mismatches quickly during inspections.

  • Insurance claims: Some policies require a reasonable match or total replacement depending on damage.

Top Strategies for Matching Asphalt Shingles

1. Find the Original Brand and Product Line

Start with identifying your current shingles:

  • Look in your attic or garage for leftover bundles or packaging.

  • Ask your original roofing contractor for the brand and color used.

  • If unsure, contact a local roofer like Roof Nuts for help identifying the make.

2. Request a Match from the Manufacturer

Major brands like Owens Corning, IKO, Malarkey, and Atlas may still produce the exact color or offer a close alternative.

Tip: Roof Nuts in Colorado (303-276-2403) and Georgia (404-476-6851) can check local distributor availability for matching products.

3. Use Leftover Shingles for Visible Areas

If you have extra shingles from your original installation, use those for the most visible spots—like the front slope—and place the closest-matching new shingles in less noticeable areas.

4. Blend the Colors Strategically

Rather than clumping new shingles in one area, interweave them with existing shingles across a larger section of roof. This reduces contrast and blends colors more effectively.

5. Let the Sun Help Over Time

UV exposure will gradually fade new shingles to more closely match older ones, especially if they’re from the same brand or series.

FAQs: Shingle Color Matching

How close does the color match need to be for insurance purposes?
It varies by policy and state law. In Colorado and Georgia, many adjusters look for a “reasonably uniform appearance.” If a close match isn't possible, full replacement may be considered.

Can I paint shingles to match?
No. According to ARMA, coating asphalt shingles is not recommended and can void warranties or cause issues with fire rating and moisture retention.

What if the exact color is discontinued?
Try contacting the manufacturer for archived stock. If not available, a roofing contractor may suggest a custom blend or full section replacement.

When to Consider Full Section Replacement

If:

  • The original shingle color is discontinued,

  • The repair area is highly visible (like front-facing slopes),

  • Or the color contrast is obvious and unacceptable,

…it may be worth investing in a full plane or slope replacement to maintain a consistent look and avoid long-term regrets.

Let Roof Nuts Help

At Roof Nuts, we specialize in roof repairs that look seamless. We know what’s in stock locally, and how to blend shingles to avoid patchy results.

Whether you need a small repair or full re-roof, we’ll make sure it looks right—and lasts.

Let us take the stress out of shingle color matching. Reach out today for a free assessment.

Custom HTML/CSS/JAVASCRIPT
Back to Blog