Shingle Roof Color Matching: How to Get a Seamless Look After Repairs

When a few shingles need replacing, you want them to blend in—not stand out. But finding an exact color match can be tricky, especially if your roof has aged or the original shingles are no longer made.

Here’s how to handle shingle color matching and what Colorado and Georgia homeowners should know before hiring a roofer.

Why Shingle Color Matching Matters

Color mismatched shingles don’t just look bad. They can also:

• Reduce curb appeal

• Raise red flags during home inspections

• Complicate insurance claims

• Signal incomplete or low-quality repairs

Whether you're patching storm damage or replacing a small area, color blending should always be part of the job.

Why Is It So Hard to Match Shingle Colors?

There are a few reasons:

• Sun exposure fades shingles over time. A new shingle from the same manufacturer may not match your older, weathered ones.

• Shingle lines change. Manufacturers discontinue styles and colors regularly. For example, ARMA (Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association) recommends checking with the original brand before trying any repairs.

• Granule blend variation. Even shingles from the same batch can look slightly different due to the mix of granules.

Options for Color Matching Shingles

1. Contact the Original Manufacturer

   • If you know the brand and style, see if they still make the same line.

   • Some companies offer color-matched repairs or similar alternatives.

2. Use Blending Techniques

   • Roofers can feather in new shingles across a wider area.

   • Instead of patching a small spot, they stagger replacements to make the color shift less noticeable.

3. Search Salvage Yards

   • Sometimes older shingles can be found from leftover stock or reclaimed roofing suppliers.

4. Consider a Full Section Replacement

   • If the color match is off, replacing a larger, more symmetrical section (like a valley or ridge) can hide the difference better.

Should You Repaint or Coat Shingles?

Don’t. According to the Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association, applying coatings over asphalt shingles is not recommended. It can trap moisture, void warranties, and cause other issues like curling or granule loss.

FAQ: Shingle Color Matching

Can you match shingles after storm damage?
Yes, but it depends on the age and type of your shingles. Insurance may cover a full replacement if no reasonable match can be found.

Is color matching required by code?
Not usually. But it may be required by your HOA or insurance company to maintain uniform appearance standards.

Can insurance replace the whole roof if colors don’t match?
Possibly. In Colorado and Georgia, if a reasonable match isn't available, some policies include "matching coverage" clauses. A professional roofer and public adjuster can help document the need.

Talk to a Roofing Expert Before You Repair

At Roof Nuts, we help homeowners in Colorado and Georgia assess shingle damage, identify manufacturer matches, and blend repairs that don’t compromise curb appeal or resale value.

Call us in Colorado at 303-276-2403 or in Georgia at 404-476-6851.
Or visit RoofNutsCO.com or RoofNutsGA.com to schedule a free inspection.