Replacing a wood shake roof in Colorado? Learn the best options for durability, fire safety, and curb appeal—plus FAQs and what type of roof is best after removing wood shakes.

Wood Shake Roof Replacement: What Colorado Homeowners Need to Know

October 19, 20253 min read

Wood Roofing Replacements: A Practical Guide for Colorado Homes

Wood shake roofs offer rustic charm and natural insulation, but they come with real limitations in Colorado's harsh climate. Between wildfire risk, hail damage, and insurance issues, many homeowners are choosing to replace wood shakes with more durable alternatives.

Here’s what you need to know if you're planning to replace a wood shake roof on your Colorado home.


Why Replace a Wood Shake Roof?

Wood shake roofs—especially cedar—used to be common in Colorado. But today, they’re often replaced due to:

  • Fire risk: Untreated wood shakes are flammable. Many local codes now limit or prohibit them in wildfire-prone areas like the foothills.

  • Insurance complications: Some insurers will not renew policies unless shakes are removed.

  • Hail and wind damage: Wood shakes split and deteriorate faster under Colorado's freeze-thaw cycles and frequent hailstorms.

  • High maintenance: They need regular inspections, cleaning, and occasional repairs to maintain water tightness.


What Are the Best Wood Shake Replacement Options?

Most Colorado homeowners choose from these five options when replacing a wood shake roof:

1. Metal Roofing (Steel or Aluminum)

  • Class A fire rating (non-combustible)

  • Extreme hail and wind resistance

  • Low maintenance and long lifespan (40–70 years)

  • Ideal for mountain and Front Range homes

2. Class 4 Impact-Resistant Asphalt Shingles

  • More affordable than metal

  • Many styles now mimic the texture of shakes

  • Eligible for insurance discounts

3. Synthetic Shake Roofing

  • Made from polymer blends or rubber composites

  • Designed to replicate the look of cedar without fire risk

  • Fire-rated and highly hail-resistant

  • Long warranties and low maintenance

4. Concrete or Clay Tiles

  • Strong and weather-resistant

  • Heavier than shakes—may require structural evaluation

  • Often seen in upscale or Mediterranean-style homes

5. Slate or Synthetic Slate

  • Very durable, but expensive

  • Best suited for steep roofs with strong structure

  • Fireproof and weather-tough


Key Considerations During a Shake Roof Replacement

  • Roof deck condition: Old wood shake roofs are often installed over spaced sheathing. Modern roofing systems usually require solid decking. Expect this to be upgraded.

  • Ventilation upgrades: Adequate attic ventilation reduces heat buildup and improves roof lifespan. Your replacement should include proper intake and exhaust vents.

  • Code compliance: Colorado's building codes vary by city (e.g., Denver, Colorado Springs, Arvada). Work with a licensed contractor familiar with local codes.

  • HOA and design review: In communities like Highlands Ranch or Boulder County, make sure your new roof material is approved.


FAQs About Wood Shake Roof Replacements

What’s the best roof to replace wood shakes with?

For most Colorado homes, a Class 4 metal or synthetic shake roof offers the best balance of durability, fire resistance, and appearance.

Do I need to replace my roof deck?

Probably. Most shake roofs are installed over skip sheathing, which must be replaced with plywood or OSB for asphalt, metal, or synthetic roofing.

Will insurance cover my shake roof replacement?

Not unless it’s storm-related damage. If you’re upgrading voluntarily, it's typically out of pocket—but you may get premium discounts after installing a Class 4 rated roof.

How long does shake roof replacement take?

Most replacements take 4–7 days, depending on roof size, material selected, and weather conditions.


Serving Colorado Homeowners

Roof Nuts CO proudly serves homeowners in Denver, Colorado Springs, Arvada, Fort Collins, and beyond. If you’re replacing a wood shake roof, we’ll walk you through your options, explain the code requirements, and help you choose a roof that protects your home for decades.

📞 Call 303-276-2403
🌐 www.RoofNutsCO.com


Custom HTML/CSS/JAVASCRIPT
Back to Blog